CarShield vs MaxCare

CarShield vs. MaxCare

When purchasing a vehicle, an extended auto warranty can provide peace of mind by covering repairs that may arise beyond the manufacturer’s warranty period. Two well-known options are CarShield and MaxCare, each offering coverage plans designed to protect drivers from unexpected costs. This comparison will explore their coverage plans, pricing structures, standout benefits, and potential drawbacks to help you decide which provider is the best fit for your needs.

Coverage plans and options

Both CarShield and MaxCare provide coverage for major vehicle components, ensuring customers are protected against costly repairs. Their plans extend beyond factory warranties and can include essential parts such as the engine, transmission, drivetrain, and electronics. Both companies also offer additional perks, including rental car reimbursement and roadside assistance.

Despite these commonalities, their coverage structures differ significantly. CarShield offers multiple plan options, allowing customers to choose from seven different levels of coverage, including specialized plans for electric vehicles, motorcycles, and high-tech electronics.

This variety makes CarShield a highly flexible choice for different types of vehicles and driving habits. In contrast, MaxCare provides a single comprehensive plan that covers most major vehicle systems but lacks the customization options CarShield offers. Additionally, MaxCare is only available for vehicles purchased through CarMax, whereas CarShield covers vehicles regardless of where they were bought.

Pricing and affordability

Both CarShield and MaxCare structure their pricing based on factors such as the make, model, mileage, and age of the vehicle. The cost of coverage varies depending on the level of protection selected, the deductible amount, and the length of the contract. 

However, their approaches to pricing are distinct. CarShield offers month-to-month payment plans, making it a flexible option for drivers who do not want to commit to long-term contracts. Monthly costs typically range between $99 and $139, with some plans available for as low as $69 per month. In contrast, MaxCare requires a one-time purchase at the time of vehicle financing, with total costs ranging between $1,000 and $5,000. While MaxCare allows customers to include the cost in their vehicle financing, it does not offer the same level of monthly payment flexibility as CarShield.

Standout benefits

Both CarShield and MaxCare offer valuable perks designed to enhance customer convenience and protection. Customers of both companies can take advantage of 24/7 roadside assistance, rental car reimbursement, and trip interruption coverage. Additionally, both providers allow customers to take their vehicles to a licensed repair facility of their choice, ensuring flexibility in where repairs are performed.

Where they differ is in their added features. CarShield offers a mobile app that allows customers to manage their plans, file claims, and access customer support more conveniently. Their coverage extends to high-mileage vehicles, with protection available for cars with up to 300,000 miles. CarShield also provides plans tailored to specific vehicle types, including electric cars and motorcycles, a feature MaxCare does not offer. MaxCare, on the other hand, allows customers to transfer their warranty to a new owner if they sell their vehicle, which can increase the car’s resale value. While CarShield warranties are also transferable, MaxCare’s integration with CarMax dealerships makes the process smoother.

Potential drawbacks

Both companies exclude routine maintenance, such as oil changes and tire rotations, from their coverage. CarShield has received mixed customer reviews regarding claim approvals, with some policyholders reporting difficulties in getting repairs covered. The company also has a strained relationship with the Better Business Bureau, receiving a low rating due to customer complaints. 

MaxCare can only be purchased at the time of a vehicle sale, limiting options for those who want to buy coverage later. Additionally, MaxCare does not provide online quotes, making it more difficult for customers to compare prices before committing. Another concern is that MaxCare is administered by a third-party company, which can lead to delays or difficulties in processing claims.

Conclusion

CarShield and MaxCare both provide extended auto warranties with roadside assistance and rental car reimbursement, but they differ in flexibility, pricing, and availability. CarShield offers multiple plans, month-to-month payments, and coverage for high-mileage and specialty vehicles. MaxCare provides a single, comprehensive plan available only through CarMax, with the option to include it in vehicle financing. The best choice depends on individual needs, budget, and whether purchasing from CarMax or seeking a broader range of coverage options.

Get Your Free Auto Warranty Quote Now