CarShield vs Everything Breaks

Everything Breaks vs. CarShield 

When it comes to protecting your vehicle from unexpected repair costs, an extended auto warranty is your best option. Two providers are trusted partners in this line of business: Everything Breaks and CarShield. While they are both extended auto warranty providers, they differ in various aspects. Keep reading for a comparison of their features, prices, subscription tiers, and more to decide which company is right for you. 

Both providers offer five main car coverage plans and include benefits like 24/7 roadside assistance, rental car reimbursement, and towing services. The most significant difference is that CarShield offers two more plans for electric vehicles and ATVs and a plan that includes benefits for vehicles that are not eligible for an extended auto warranty. 

Everything Break’s coverage plans are scalable and adapt to any changing needs; however, the cons of their plans include a short duration of three years at a time, a maximum of 240,000 miles, and a high cancellation fee of $75. On the other hand, CarShield’s plans are comprehensive, fit high-mileage vehicles, and have low to no deductibles but may not cover hybrid vehicles and all expenses. 

When it comes to pricing, Everything Breaks is as flexible as can be. They provide monthly and yearly payments with transparent pricing, and you can expect to pay anywhere between $29 to $109 monthly, depending on the plan you purchase. While CarShield does not advertise set prices and bases them on a number of factors like vehicle age, mileage, and other factors, they cost an average of $69.99 to $200 per month. 

Both providers aim to make the claim process as straightforward as possible. Both providers give you the option to repair your vehicle at any ASE-certified repair facility, and every claim requires approval beforehand, or else you will not be reimbursed. It is essential to read the terms and conditions for each company thoroughly to understand the claims process for the plan you select. 

To evaluate the customer experience, independent reviews are crucial to understanding how these companies perform in practice. Everything Breaks has gained positive feedback for its responsive customer service and straightforward claims process. Customers appreciate the company's willingness to address concerns and guide them through claims efficiently. In contrast, the negative reviews surround being unable to cancel warranty plans and the fact that some customers have not received the coverage they were expecting. 

CarShield has also received positive reviews for its extensive coverage options, reliability, and extremely responsive customer support. However, some negative reviews mention that there is difficulty canceling plans, that some repair shops do not accept CarShield’s plans, and that coverage is denied for certain parts despite being told they are included.  

In summary, both providers are respected in the extended auto warranty industry. If you’re looking for affordable plans, payment flexibility, and online cancellation at any time, then Everything Breaks is your provider. Alternatively, if you are seeking high-mileage comprehensive coverage for a wide variety of vehicle types and conditions, then CarShield is the provider for you.  

Ultimately, the decision should be made based on your vehicle's needs, budget, and preference for a more comprehensive protection approach beyond just your vehicle. 

Get Your Free Auto Warranty Quote Now