ASC Warranty vs Endurance

ASC Warranty vs. Endurance

When it comes to extended auto warranties, ASC Warranty and Endurance are two well-known providers that offer different approaches to vehicle protection. While both companies provide coverage for unexpected repairs and breakdowns, their plans, pricing, and customer service models differ.

This comparison explores their coverage plans, pricing structures, standout benefits, and potential drawbacks to help you determine which might be the better fit for your vehicle.

Coverage plans and options

Both ASC Warranty and Endurance provide a range of vehicle service contracts designed to cover major repairs, including engine, transmission, and electrical system failures. They also offer additional benefits such as rental car reimbursement and roadside assistance, ensuring customers receive support in case of breakdowns.

However, their plan structures differ significantly. In the case of ASC Warranty, there are four main coverage levels: Drivetrain Plus, Platinum Drivetrain, Deluxe Coverage, and Factory-Type Coverage. Their Factory-Type Coverage is the most comprehensive, mimicking manufacturer warranties, while the Drivetrain Plus plan covers only essential powertrain components. ASC also provides supplemental coverage that can extend factory powertrain warranties.

Endurance, on the other hand, provides five customizable plans: Secure, Secure Plus, Superior, Supreme, and Supreme Wrap. Their Supreme plan is an exclusionary policy covering nearly all vehicle components, whereas Secure is their most affordable powertrain plan. Additionally, Endurance offers optional high-tech, hybrid vehicle, and commercial-use add-ons.

Pricing

ASC Warranty does not provide quotes online; pricing depends on the dealership where the policy is purchased. On average, ASC plans range between $600 and $1,000 for six months of coverage, but specific pricing details require direct inquiries.

Endurance follows a quote-based pricing model, offering plans between $70 and $125 per month, depending on the vehicle’s make, model, and mileage. They provide various discounts, including military, government employee, and first-time caller discounts.

Standout benefits

Both companies offer several benefits, but their standout features cater to different priorities:
ASC Warranty’s strongest benefits include:

• $0 deductible on all plans, eliminating out-of-pocket expenses for covered repairs
• Live chat support, an uncommon feature among warranty providers, allowing quick access to customer service
• Supplemental warranty coverage that extends factory powertrain protection
• On-the-spot payment for repairs, meaning customers don’t have to pay upfront and wait for reimbursement

Endurance’s strongest benefits include:

• Direct provider model, eliminating third-party administrators and simplifying claims
• Elite Benefits package, which includes tire replacement, collision discounts, and key fob replacement
• Customizable plans with hybrid and commercial vehicle add-ons, making coverage more flexible
• A mobile app and online portal for easy contract management

Potential drawbacks

Neither provider covers pre-existing conditions or routine maintenance, which is standard across most extended warranty companies. However, each has unique disadvantages to consider:
ASC Warranty’s drawbacks include:

• No online quote tool, requiring customers to visit a dealership for pricing
• Limited mileage coverage (up to 120,000 miles), whereas competitors, including Endurance, offer coverage for vehicles up to 250,000 miles
• Lack of transparency, as plan details, pricing, and waiting periods are not clearly listed on their website

Endurance’s drawbacks include:

• Higher pricing, making them less suitable for budget-conscious consumers
• Some customer complaints regarding the claims process, with occasional delays or disputes over covered repairs
• Additional fees for high-tech and commercial vehicle coverage, which other companies may include as standard

Conclusion

Both ASC Warranty and Endurance provide solid extended warranty coverage, but their differences make them better suited for different types of customers:

ASC Warranty is ideal for those who prefer dealership-based warranties and a $0 deductible, especially if they purchase a new car and want to extend the factory powertrain warranty.

Endurance is a better option for those looking for a direct provider with flexible, customizable plans and transparent pricing.

Ultimately, Endurance is the better choice for those who want comprehensive coverage, digital access to plan details, and more control over their contract. However, ASC Warranty appeals to those who want straightforward coverage with no deductibles and dealership-backed security.

Get Your Free Auto Warranty Quote Now!