America Auto Care vs MaxCare

Founded in 2016 and headquartered in Stuart, Florida, America Auto Care is a third-party vehicle service contract provider offering four levels of repair coverage. Their plans range from Basic Coverage for the engine, transmission, and drive axles to broader options covering systems such as the suspension, brakes, air conditioning, heating, and luxury electronics.

All coverage levels include towing and roadside assistance, and customers can use ASE-certified repair facilities across the United States and Canada. The provider also advertises no-fee payment plans, a 30-day full-refund period, and transferable coverage in many cases. Pricing, deductibles, vehicle eligibility limits, and waiting periods are not published online, so customers must request a quote and review their contract for these details.

America Auto Care holds an A+ BBB rating but is not accredited by the organization. Their BBB profile also lists a Florida Department of Financial Services license. ConsumerAffairs gives the company a 4.2 out of 5 rating, although most detailed customer reviews are several years old. This review examines their coverage, costs, contract terms, customer experiences, and potential limitations in greater detail.

MaxCare is an extended vehicle service contract introduced by CarMax in 2009, available exclusively at the time of purchasing a vehicle through their dealership network. Unlike many third-party warranty providers that offer multiple plan tiers, MaxCare uses a single exclusionary coverage model, similar to a factory bumper-to-bumper warranty, covering most mechanical and electrical components except for a defined list of exclusions. Contracts are tailored to each vehicle, with coverage typically extending up to 75,000 to 150,000 total odometer miles. While CarMax facilitates the customer experience, the plans are administered by third-party providers such as Fidelity Warranty Services and CNA National Warranty Corporation. Key benefits include 24/7 roadside assistance, rental car reimbursement, transferable coverage, and flexible payment options, including rolling the cost into monthly financing. A $50 deductible discount is also offered when using CarMax service centers or RepairPal-certified shops. Customer feedback is mixed, with many reporting strong coverage for major repairs, while others cite delays, strict claim requirements, and challenges when working with independent repair facilities.