CarvanaCare vs Premier Auto Protect

Carvana Care is a vehicle service contract program available to eligible buyers purchasing a vehicle through Carvana. Founded in 2012 and headquartered in Tempe, Arizona, they integrate coverage directly into the online vehicle buying process, allowing many customers to include the cost in their financing. They offer three coverage levels, Essential, Plus, and Premier, with benefits that include roadside assistance, rental reimbursement, and additional maintenance and cosmetic protection on higher-tier plans. Claims are administered by SilverRock through a nationwide repair network. Carvana holds an A+ rating from the Better Business Bureau, although they are not BBB accredited, and they maintain a strong Trustpilot rating based on thousands of customer reviews. This review examines their coverage options, pricing, contract terms, claims process, customer experience, and support resources to help you better understand whether Carvana Care is the right choice for your vehicle protection needs.

Premier Auto Protect is a New York-based vehicle service contract provider founded in 2016. They offer nationwide coverage and operate as a direct provider, handling both plan administration and customer service. Their coverage options range from basic Powertrain protection to comprehensive Exclusionary plans, with additional options available for electric vehicles through a dedicated EV Exclusionary plan. Many of their contracts include benefits such as roadside assistance, rental car reimbursement, trip interruption coverage, and access to ASE-certified repair facilities across the country. Coverage is available for a variety of vehicle types, including used vehicles, higher-mileage vehicles, hybrids, and EVs. The company holds Better Business Bureau accreditation and an A BBB rating. Customer feedback is generally positive on larger review platforms, including Trustpilot and the BBB, where many reviewers praise the sales experience, customer service, and coverage options. At the same time, some customers report concerns related to claims processing, contract interpretation, and coverage disputes, making it important to understand the details of any agreement before purchasing. This review takes a closer look at their plans, costs, contract terms, customer experiences, and support resources to help readers better understand what Premier Auto Protect offers.