trusted formADP TotalSource vs BBSI PEO vs Fourth vs Horizons PEO vs More... | Several.com
Although we earn commissions from partners, we ensure unbiased evaluations. More on our 'How We Work' page

ADP TotalSource vs BBSI PEO vs Fourth vs Horizons PEO vs More...

Press [Add to Compare] to Edit, Add or Remove Vendors

Pros
  • Excellent payroll services
  • Automatic employee tracking
  • Multiple packages for different business sizes
  • Easy mobile app
  • Employee self-service
Pros
  • Employee Self-Service Portal
  • Expert HR guidance
  • Industry specific services
Pros
  • Live chat support
  • Dedicated professional HR team
  • Available demo
Pros
  • Extensive features
  • User-friendly interface
  • Cost-effective solutions
  • Customizable plans
  • Local HR experts
Pros
  • Only a 30-day cancelation notice
  • Allows employees to contact PEO directly
  • All-in-one cloud-based software
  • Fortune-500-level benefits
  • Doesn't require lengthy commitments
Pros
  • A+ rated and accredited by the BBB
  • Financial Wellness Program
  • Employee self-service options
  • Excellent customer support options
  • Mobile app
  • Affordable prices and customizable plans
  • Simple and up-to-date all-in-one software
Cons
  • Interface may be confusing
  • May be expensive
  • Does not advertise prices
Cons
  • Lack of pricing transparency
  • No mobile application
  • No demo
  • Not IRS-certified
  • Fewer offices across the country
Cons
  • Not ESAC accredited
  • Lack of transparency
Cons
  • Lack of pricing transparency
  • No demo
  • No mobile app
  • No industry certifications
Cons
  • Lack of price or plan transparency
  • Lengthy setup time
  • May be pricey with many paid add-ons
  • Clients must have five employees minimum
Cons
  • May be charged extra for some necessary features
  • Difficulties with custom reports & onboarding
  • May require over 5 employees
Summary

ADP TotalSource (NASDAQ – ADP) provides a comprehensive cloud-based solution for employee life cycle management that spans HR administration, talent management, employee benefits, payroll, and regulatory compliance. They have over 60 years of experience and employ many professionals in HR, talent, and compliance, which they use to give you considerable purchasing power for premium advantages—  without the premium costs. They offer four payroll options that serve all business sizes, with features that range from basic payroll, taxes, and compliance assistance all the way to a premium suite of tools that includes HR support, training, business advice, and legal assistance. Pricing information for these options is not advertised as it is tailored to company size and requirements, so you must fill out a form for a quote. They are a large PEO company that claims to have more than 80% of the Fortune 500 businesses as clients and around one million clients in 140 countries, and they accordingly employ over 60,000 associates to meet their clients' needs.
 

Summary

BBSI (Barrett Business Services Inc.) is a PEO founded in 1972, starting out as a staffing company. BBSI, which is also its symbol on NASDAQ, is headquartered in Vancouver, WA. It provides its services to small and medium-sized businesses (SMBs) spanning eight industries. They serve all 50 states in the US, with offices in 14 states. Their services include business strategy, HR consultation, risk and safety, payroll administration, workers' compensation, staffing and recruitment, employee benefits, retirement benefits, and various technology solutions. With a team of people who meet with clients on-site to understand their culture and dedication to establishing a safe workplace, BBSI provides businesses with customized services. They do not specify plans or pricing on their website, preferring prospective clients to contact them so that they can "create a pricing structure that fits their needs." They are certified by the Employer Services Assurance Corporation (ESAC), whose accreditation is considered the gold standard for PEO reliability and financial assurance. They have repeatedly earned the yearly "Great Place to Work" certification.

Summary

Fourth PEO, a leading Human Capital Management (HCM) software company headquartered in Austin, Texas, specializes in Professional Employer Organization (PEO) services for small and medium-sized businesses (SMBs). With a foundation in HCM since 1999, they have expanded into the PEO sphere, incorporating AI-driven technology into their platform. Catering to industries like restaurant, hospitality, and retail, Fourth offers a range of services, including payroll, HR solutions, benefits administration, tax management, and compliance assistance. While praised for live chat support, a dedicated HR team, and AI-driven tech, drawbacks include the lack of ESAC accreditation and limited pricing transparency. Despite some mixed customer feedback, Fourth remains a reputable choice for SMBs seeking streamlined business operations.

Summary

Horizons' holistic approach and diverse set of global PEO and EOR services cater to the HR needs of businesses, providing support in crucial areas such as compliance, payroll management, benefits administration, and expert guidance. This enables companies to effectively manage their workforce, ensure compliance, and focus on strategic business objectives while Horizons manages the complexities of HR.

Summary

Small to medium-sized businesses (SMBs) can obtain human resources and business solutions from Insperity, which was established in 1986 and has over 90 locations nationwide. Many of the administrative, financial, and legal duties associated with managing a human resources department are handled by Insperity's cloud-based HR solution. With its corporate headquarters in King of Prussia, Pennsylvania, Insperity (NYSE: NSP) employs over 6,000 people and has over 100,000 customers in the US. Insperity offers a wide range of HR and business solutions, including payroll, employee benefits administration, HR administration, worker's compensation, employment law compliance, talent management, and business consulting. They received IRS certification demonstrating their stability and responsibility after meeting stringent financial and experience requirements, which recognizes them as a CPEO. They offer three HR solution options on their website that vary according to the size and requirements of the business, but they do not list the costs for those plans there. Insperity's services can help SMBs with HR-related activities while saving money and time. They can assist companies in attracting top employees and observing employment regulations.

Summary

Paychex is a leading supplier of comprehensive human capital management systems for payroll, employee benefits, human resources, retirement plans, and business insurance services in the US and Northern Europe. Paychex, Inc. (NASDAQ: PAYX) was founded in 1971 and has more than 730,000 client companies, mostly small to medium-sized businesses but also larger businesses. They are considered one of the top companies in their field, claiming to pay 1 in 12 employees in the private sector. They offer three package categories tailored to fit a business's size and needs, with flexible payment options. They also boast easy-to-use online services and expert consultants that ensure proper federal and state compliance and can get you valuable tax credits and phone and online support. Paychex services vary according to the organization's needs and size, with a base monthly cost of $39 plus $5 per employee.

Quick Stats
  • Business Size : Small to medium-sized businesses (SMBs)
  • Cost : Not advertised
  • Customer Experience : Excellent
  • IRS-Certified : True
  • Expert HR Guidance : True
  • BBB Rating : A+
  • NAPEO Member : True
  • ESAC Accreditation : True
Quick Stats
  • Business Size : Small and medium-sized (SMB)
  • Cost : Quote-based
  • Customer Experience : Good
  • IRS-Certified : False
  • Expert HR Guidance : True
  • BBB Rating : 3 out of 5
  • Trustpilot Score : N/R
  • NAPEO Member : True
  • ESAC Accreditation : True
Quick Stats
  • Business Size : Small and medium-sized (SMB)
  • Cost : Quote-based
  • Customer Experience : Good
  • IRS-Certified : True
  • Expert HR Guidance : True
  • BBB Rating : N/R
  • Trustpilot Score : N/R
  • NAPEO Member : False
  • ESAC Accreditation : False
Quick Stats
  • Business Size : Undisclosed
  • Cost : Starting at $299
  • Customer Experience : Good
  • IRS-Certified : False
  • Expert HR Guidance : True
  • BBB Rating : N/R
  • Trustpilot Score : 4.6 out of 5
  • NAPEO Member : False
  • ESAC Accreditation : False
Quick Stats
  • Business Size : Small and medium-sized (SMB)
  • Cost : Quote-based
  • Customer Experience : Fair
  • IRS-Certified : False
  • Expert HR Guidance : True
  • BBB Rating : A+
  • Trustpilot Score : 2.7 out of 5
  • NAPEO Member : True
  • ESAC Accreditation : True
Quick Stats
  • Business Size : Any
  • Cost : Starts at $39 + $5 per employee/month
  • Customer Experience : Excellent
  • IRS-Certified : True
  • Expert HR Guidance : True
  • BBB Rating : A+
  • Trustpilot Score : 1.2 out of 5
  • NAPEO Member : True
  • ESAC Accreditation : True
Selling Points
  • Comprehensive HR, talent, and compliance
  • Automatic employee tracking
  • Powerful technology and data-driven insights
  • Mobile app
  • Online product demo
  • AI-driven principles, such as for candidate relevancy
Selling Points
  • Pay-as-you-go workers' compensation model
  • They offer a Business Unit
  • Dedicated business strategy
Selling Points
  • Available demo
  • Mobile app & AI-driven tech
Selling Points
  • They operate in 180+ countries
  • Dedicated business strategy
  • Pay-as-you-go workers' compensation model
Selling Points
  • Flexible & easily cancelable agreements
  • Scalable services for growing companies
  • Excellent small-business management & growth solutions
Selling Points
  • A+ rated and accredited by the BBB
  • Responsive expert guidance
  • Comprehensive HR technologies & integrations
  • Excellent customer support options
  • Fully-featured PEO and HR solutions
Business Size Supported
  • Undisclosed
    Large Businesses
  • Medium-Sized Businesses
  • Small Businesses
Business Size Supported
  • Large Businesses
  • Medium-Sized Businesses
  • Small Businesses
Business Size Supported
  • Large Businesses
  • Medium-Sized Businesses
  • Small Businesses
Business Size Supported
  • Undisclosed
    Large Businesses
  • Undisclosed
    Medium-Sized Businesses
  • Undisclosed
    Small Businesses
Business Size Supported
  • Large Businesses
  • Medium-Sized Businesses
  • Small Businesses
Business Size Supported
  • Large Businesses
  • Medium-Sized Businesses
  • Small Businesses
Employee Benefits
  • 401(k)
  • Accident
  • COBRA Administration
  • Critical Illness
  • Disability
  • Employee Self-Service
  • HSA/FSA
  • Medical, Dental, Vision
  • Shopping & Entertainment Discounts
  • Work-Life Employee Assistance Program
Employee Benefits
  • 401(k)
  • Accident
  • Undisclosed
    COBRA Administration
  • Undisclosed
    Critical Illness
  • Undisclosed
    Disability
  • Employee Self-Service
  • Undisclosed
    HSA/FSA
  • Undisclosed
    Medical, Dental, Vision
  • Shopping & Entertainment Discounts
  • Undisclosed
    Work-Life Employee Assistance Program
Employee Benefits
  • 401(k)
  • Undisclosed
    Accident
  • COBRA Administration
  • Undisclosed
    Critical Illness
  • Undisclosed
    Disability
  • Employee Self-Service
  • HSA/FSA
  • Undisclosed
    Medical, Dental, Vision
  • Shopping & Entertainment Discounts
  • Work-Life Employee Assistance Program
Employee Benefits
  • Undisclosed
    401(k)
  • Undisclosed
    Accident
  • Undisclosed
    COBRA Administration
  • Undisclosed
    Critical Illness
  • Undisclosed
    Disability
  • Employee Self-Service
  • Undisclosed
    HSA/FSA
  • Undisclosed
    Medical, Dental, Vision
  • Undisclosed
    Shopping & Entertainment Discounts
  • Undisclosed
    Work-Life Employee Assistance Program
Employee Benefits
  • 401(k)
  • Accident
  • Undisclosed
    COBRA Administration
  • Undisclosed
    Critical Illness
  • Disability
  • Employee Self-Service
  • HSA/FSA
  • Medical, Dental, Vision
  • Undisclosed
    Shopping & Entertainment Discounts
  • Undisclosed
    Work-Life Employee Assistance Program
Employee Benefits
  • 401(k)
  • Accident
  • COBRA Administration
  • Undisclosed
    Critical Illness
  • Disability
  • Employee Self-Service
  • HSA/FSA
  • Medical, Dental, Vision
  • Undisclosed
    Shopping & Entertainment Discounts
  • Undisclosed
    Work-Life Employee Assistance Program
HR Management
  • Onboarding
  • Report Builder
  • Risk Mitigation
  • Time & Attendance
  • Unemployment Insurance
  • Workers' Compensation
  • Workplace Compliance & Safety
HR Management
  • Onboarding
  • Report Builder
  • Risk Mitigation
  • Time & Attendance
  • Undisclosed
    Unemployment Insurance
  • Workers' Compensation
  • Workplace Compliance & Safety
HR Management
  • Onboarding
  • Report Builder
  • Risk Mitigation
  • Time & Attendance
  • Unemployment Insurance
  • Workers' Compensation
  • Workplace Compliance & Safety
HR Management
  • Onboarding
  • Report Builder
  • Risk Mitigation
  • Undisclosed
    Time & Attendance
  • Undisclosed
    Unemployment Insurance
  • Workers' Compensation
  • Workplace Compliance & Safety
HR Management
  • Onboarding
  • Report Builder
  • Risk Mitigation
  • Time & Attendance
  • Unemployment Insurance
  • Workers' Compensation
  • Workplace Compliance & Safety
HR Management
  • Onboarding
  • Report Builder
  • Risk Mitigation
  • Time & Attendance
  • Unemployment Insurance
  • Workers' Compensation
  • Workplace Compliance & Safety
Payroll Services
  • Direct Deposit
  • Garnishments
  • Undisclosed
    Global Payroll
  • Payroll History & Tracking
  • Reimbursement Management
  • Salary Revision & Raise Management
  • Tax Services
  • Time-Off Requests & Scheduling
  • US Payroll
Payroll Services
  • Direct Deposit
  • Undisclosed
    Garnishments
  • Global Payroll
  • Payroll History & Tracking
  • Undisclosed
    Reimbursement Management
  • Salary Revision & Raise Management
  • Tax Services
  • Undisclosed
    Time-Off Requests & Scheduling
  • US Payroll
Payroll Services
  • Direct Deposit
  • Garnishments
  • Global Payroll
  • Payroll History & Tracking
  • Reimbursement Management
  • Salary Revision & Raise Management
  • Tax Services
  • Time-Off Requests & Scheduling
  • US Payroll
Payroll Services
  • Undisclosed
    Direct Deposit
  • Undisclosed
    Garnishments
  • Global Payroll
  • Payroll History & Tracking
  • Undisclosed
    Reimbursement Management
  • Salary Revision & Raise Management
  • Tax Services
  • Undisclosed
    Time-Off Requests & Scheduling
  • US Payroll
Payroll Services
  • Direct Deposit
  • Garnishments
  • Undisclosed
    Global Payroll
  • Payroll History & Tracking
  • Reimbursement Management
  • Undisclosed
    Salary Revision & Raise Management
  • Tax Services
  • Time-Off Requests & Scheduling
  • US Payroll
Payroll Services
  • Direct Deposit
  • Garnishments
  • Undisclosed
    Global Payroll
  • Payroll History & Tracking
  • Reimbursement Management
  • Salary Revision & Raise Management
  • Tax Services
  • Time-Off Requests & Scheduling
  • US Payroll
Technology Platform
  • All-In-One Software Tool
  • Cloud Analytics, Insights, & Reporting
  • Customized Reports
  • Global EOR Platform
  • Undisclosed
    Third-Party Cloud Application Integration
  • Virtual Assistance
Technology Platform
  • All-In-One Software Tool
  • Undisclosed
    Cloud Analytics, Insights, & Reporting
  • Customized Reports
  • Global EOR Platform
  • Undisclosed
    Third-Party Cloud Application Integration
  • Virtual Assistance
Technology Platform
  • All-In-One Software Tool
  • Cloud Analytics, Insights, & Reporting
  • Customized Reports
  • Global EOR Platform
  • Third-Party Cloud Application Integration
  • Virtual Assistance
Technology Platform
  • All-In-One Software Tool
  • Cloud Analytics, Insights, & Reporting
  • Customized Reports
  • Global EOR Platform
  • Undisclosed
    Third-Party Cloud Application Integration
  • Undisclosed
    Virtual Assistance
Technology Platform
  • All-In-One Software Tool
  • Cloud Analytics, Insights, & Reporting
  • Customized Reports
  • Undisclosed
    Global EOR Platform
  • Undisclosed
    Third-Party Cloud Application Integration
  • Virtual Assistance
Technology Platform
  • All-In-One Software Tool
  • Cloud Analytics, Insights, & Reporting
  • Customized Reports
  • Undisclosed
    Global EOR Platform
  • Undisclosed
    Third-Party Cloud Application Integration
  • Virtual Assistance
Industries
  • Construction
  • Undisclosed
    Consulting
  • Undisclosed
    E-Commerce
  • Education
  • Undisclosed
    Engineering
  • Financial Services
  • Food & Beverage
  • Government
  • Healthcare
  • Hospitality
  • Undisclosed
    Legal Services
  • Undisclosed
    Life Sciences
  • Manufacturing
  • Undisclosed
    Marketing/Advertising
  • Undisclosed
    Media/Entertainment
  • Nonprofit/Social Services
  • Professional/Technical Services
  • Retail
  • Undisclosed
    Technology
Industries
  • Construction
  • Consulting
  • E-Commerce
  • Education
  • Engineering
  • Financial Services
  • Food & Beverage
  • Government
  • Healthcare
  • Hospitality
  • Legal Services
  • Life Sciences
  • Manufacturing
  • Marketing/Advertising
  • Media/Entertainment
  • Nonprofit/Social Services
  • Professional/Technical Services
  • Retail
  • Technology
Industries
  • Construction
  • Consulting
  • E-Commerce
  • Education
  • Engineering
  • Financial Services
  • Food & Beverage
  • Government
  • Healthcare
  • Hospitality
  • Legal Services
  • Life Sciences
  • Manufacturing
  • Marketing/Advertising
  • Media/Entertainment
  • Undisclosed
    Nonprofit/Social Services
  • Professional/Technical Services
  • Retail
  • Technology
Industries
  • Undisclosed
    Construction
  • Undisclosed
    Consulting
  • Undisclosed
    E-Commerce
  • Undisclosed
    Education
  • Undisclosed
    Engineering
  • Undisclosed
    Financial Services
  • Undisclosed
    Food & Beverage
  • Undisclosed
    Government
  • Undisclosed
    Healthcare
  • Undisclosed
    Hospitality
  • Undisclosed
    Legal Services
  • Undisclosed
    Life Sciences
  • Undisclosed
    Manufacturing
  • Undisclosed
    Marketing/Advertising
  • Undisclosed
    Media/Entertainment
  • Undisclosed
    Nonprofit/Social Services
  • Undisclosed
    Professional/Technical Services
  • Undisclosed
    Retail
  • Undisclosed
    Technology
Industries
  • Construction
  • Consulting
  • Undisclosed
    E-Commerce
  • Undisclosed
    Education
  • Engineering
  • Financial Services
  • Undisclosed
    Food & Beverage
  • Undisclosed
    Government
  • Healthcare
  • Undisclosed
    Hospitality
  • Legal Services
  • Undisclosed
    Life Sciences
  • Manufacturing
  • Undisclosed
    Marketing/Advertising
  • Undisclosed
    Media/Entertainment
  • Nonprofit/Social Services
  • Undisclosed
    Professional/Technical Services
  • Retail
  • Technology
Industries
  • Construction
  • Undisclosed
    Consulting
  • Undisclosed
    E-Commerce
  • Undisclosed
    Education
  • Undisclosed
    Engineering
  • Undisclosed
    Financial Services
  • Food & Beverage
  • Undisclosed
    Government
  • Healthcare
  • Hospitality
  • Undisclosed
    Legal Services
  • Undisclosed
    Life Sciences
  • Undisclosed
    Manufacturing
  • Undisclosed
    Marketing/Advertising
  • Undisclosed
    Media/Entertainment
  • Undisclosed
    Nonprofit/Social Services
  • Professional/Technical Services
  • Retail
  • Undisclosed
    Technology
Additional Perks
  • Comprehensive Resume Search & Service
  • Early Access to Earned Pay
  • Student Loan Repayment Program
  • Talent Growth & Retention
  • Third-Party HCM Integration
Additional Perks
  • Comprehensive Resume Search & Service
  • Undisclosed
    Early Access to Earned Pay
  • Student Loan Repayment Program
  • Talent Growth & Retention
  • Third-Party HCM Integration
Additional Perks
  • Comprehensive Resume Search & Service
  • Early Access to Earned Pay
  • Student Loan Repayment Program
  • Talent Growth & Retention
  • Third-Party HCM Integration
Additional Perks
  • Comprehensive Resume Search & Service
  • Undisclosed
    Early Access to Earned Pay
  • Undisclosed
    Student Loan Repayment Program
  • Undisclosed
    Talent Growth & Retention
  • Undisclosed
    Third-Party HCM Integration
Additional Perks
  • Undisclosed
    Comprehensive Resume Search & Service
  • Undisclosed
    Early Access to Earned Pay
  • Student Loan Repayment Program
  • Talent Growth & Retention
  • Undisclosed
    Third-Party HCM Integration
Additional Perks
  • Undisclosed
    Comprehensive Resume Search & Service
  • Undisclosed
    Early Access to Earned Pay
  • Undisclosed
    Student Loan Repayment Program
  • Undisclosed
    Talent Growth & Retention
  • Third-Party HCM Integration
Customer Support
  • Undisclosed
    Email
  • FAQs
  • Undisclosed
    Help Guides
  • Live Chat
  • Mobile App
  • Phone
Customer Support
  • Email
  • FAQs
  • Help Guides
  • Live Chat
  • Mobile App
  • Phone
Customer Support
  • Email
  • FAQs
  • Help Guides
  • Live Chat
  • Mobile App
  • Phone
Customer Support
  • Email
  • FAQs
  • Help Guides
  • Live Chat
  • Mobile App
  • Phone
Customer Support
  • Email
  • FAQs
  • Help Guides
  • Live Chat
  • Mobile App
  • Phone
Customer Support
  • Undisclosed
    Email
  • FAQs
  • Undisclosed
    Help Guides
  • Live Chat
  • Mobile App
  • Phone

Save Big on PEO

Fill out a quick form to claim special offers on PEO

image