Allegiance vs Colonial Van Lines

Allegiance vs. Colonial Van Lines

Moving long distance is less about the truck and more about the process. These two companies both focus on interstate moves, but they run them in different ways, which can change how predictable your timeline, pricing, and support feel.

Services and availability

Allegiance Van Lines focuses on long-distance and interstate moves, with packing, loading, transport, and storage as core add-ons. Their site highlights planning resources and a structured intake process, and their public contact details place them in Pompano Beach, Florida. 

Colonial Van Lines also centers on long-distance and interstate relocations across the contiguous U.S., with options like packing, storage, and specialty item handling. Their site positions them as a full-service mover with corporate relocation support and planning tools.

Reliability and moving experience

Allegiance has a BBB rating of B and is not BBB accredited. Reviews show a split pattern: many customers praise the moving crew on pickup and delivery days, while complaints often focus on deposits, price changes, communication gaps, and how issues get handled when something goes wrong.

Colonial has a BBB rating of A+ and is not BBB accredited. Reviews often describe strong coordination when inventory and expectations are clear, with recurring negatives around delays, damage claims, and billing disputes tied to weight, add-ons, or changes after the initial quote. Colonial also presents themselves as a carrier-led mover with centralized coordination, which may reduce handoffs compared to broker-style bookings, but it does not eliminate variability tied to crews and logistics.

Pricing and value

Allegiance pricing appears to be quote-based rather than packaged, with emphasis on estimating tied to inventory review rather than quick phone math. The practical upside is fewer surprises when the survey is thorough. The tradeoff is that disputes can still happen when shipment size changes, access factors trigger extra labor, or storage and specialty handling get added late. For insurance, they operate in the standard valuation world common to interstate moving, where coverage level and packing rules can affect claim outcomes.

Colonial also prices moves individually. Their estimate process is typically built around a virtual or phone survey and can involve binding or non-binding structures depending on the shipment and review. Value tends to be strongest when the inventory list is detailed, and the contract clearly lists potential access fees like long carries, stairs, or shuttles. Colonial also promotes storage and packing as modular add-ons, which can help match service level to budget, but can raise totals quickly on larger homes or peak season dates.

Conclusion

Allegiance tends to fit moves where the priority is a guided planning process and optional storage built into the timeline, with extra care taken to document inventory and terms upfront. They look best for customers who want a coordinator-led experience and are willing to read the contract closely, confirm who handles each leg of the move, and keep a paper trail for pricing and claims.

Colonial tends to fit customers who want a long-distance specialist with an established national footprint, structured coordination, and a broad menu of full-service options. They look strongest for cross-country or multi-state moves, where planning discipline matters and the customer wants a single carrier-branded process and clearer guardrails around estimates, add-ons, and valuation choices.