Car Dealership
Top Companies in 2025
AutoNation vs Carvana Car Dealership
Press [Add to Compare] to Edit, Add or Remove Vendors
- Straightforward pricing approach at many locations
- Strong online tools for financing, trade-ins, and vehicle browsing
- Multiple financing options through partnered lenders
- Wide nationwide network with extensive inventory variety
- Large service and maintenance network for long-term support
- Straightforward, no-haggle pricing for predictable costs
- Seven-day return period that gives buyers real driving time
- Fast online pre-qualification with soft credit checks
- Convenient trade-in process integrated into checkout
- Limited responsiveness to complaints or follow-up issues
- Reports of unexpected costs or add-on pressure during financing
- Customer experience varies significantly by location
- Lower ratings on major review platforms compared to competitors
- Customer support quality varies across cases and locations
- Shipping and delivery fees can add up, especially for exchanges
- Title, paperwork, or scheduling issues may cause delays
AutoNation has grown into one of the largest automotive retailers in the United States since opening their first location in 1996 in Fort Lauderdale, Florida, where they remain headquartered. Their nationwide network spans hundreds of dealerships offering new and used vehicles, financing assistance, certified service centers, collision repair, trade-in options, and digital tools that let customers browse inventory, compare pricing, and start the buying process online. Their clear-pricing approach and broad selection attract shoppers looking for convenience and predictability, while their long-term service infrastructure supports drivers throughout ownership. Customer feedback varies widely across locations, with some praising attentive staff and smooth experiences, while others report communication issues, unresolved service concerns, or unexpected costs. They are not accredited by the Better Business Bureau and currently hold a rating of 1.32 out of 5, which reflects mixed satisfaction levels across their network. Despite the varied feedback, their scale, availability, and flexible shopping options make them a major player in the industry. Readers interested in how these strengths and limitations play out across different stages of the car-buying journey will find deeper insights throughout this full review.
Carvana is an online used-car retailer founded in 2012 and headquartered in Tempe, Arizona. They built their service around a digital-first model that lets buyers browse vehicles, secure financing, complete paperwork, and arrange delivery or pickup without visiting a physical dealership. Their nationwide inventory, no-haggle pricing, and detailed listings appeal to shoppers who want a straightforward way to compare models and costs. Features like soft credit pre-qualification, trade-in offers, and a seven-day return period add flexibility, while every purchase includes a standard 100-day limited warranty for early-stage protection. Their acquisition of ADESA U.S. expanded their operational footprint and strengthened their logistics network, supporting faster delivery and broader inventory movement across the country. Customer feedback is mixed across platforms: Trustpilot shows strong satisfaction with a 4.3 rating, while their BBB profile displays a lower 1.11 rating, highlighting concerns about vehicle condition, communication, and support consistency. Despite this contrast, the volume of reviews reflects an active customer base and a service model that continues to attract buyers seeking an alternative to traditional dealership experiences. This review explores how their platform works, what you can expect from their features, and whether their approach fits your needs as a car buyer.
- Auto Loan Option : {"id":"Available"}
- Financing Options : Available
- Locations Served : 300+ locations across the United States
- Qualified Mechanics : Available
- Servicing Departments : Most locations include full-service departments; availability may vary by store
- Vehicle Types Inventory : {"id":"Both"}
- Auto Loan Option : {"id":"Available"}
- Financing Options : Selling, buying, and financing cars
- Locations Served : Delivery and pickup coverage across most U.S. regions; inventory available nationwide
- Qualified Mechanics : Not Available
- Servicing Departments : Unavailable (they do not run physical service departments; warranty repairs are handled through SilverRock partner shops)
- Vehicle Types Inventory : {"id":"Used"}
- One of the largest dealership networks in the United States
- Clear-pricing model that reduces negotiation stress
- Integrated online-to-store buying experience for flexible shopping
- Mobile service availability in select markets for added convenience
- Fully online buying process that eliminates dealership visits
- Home delivery and pickup options in many regions
- Standard 100-day limited warranty included with every purchase
- Digital platform designed for a pressure-free car-shopping experience
- New Cars
- Used Cars
- New Cars—Undisclosed
- Used Cars
- FAQs
- Help Guides
- Live Chat
- Mobile Application
- Phone
- Ticket
- FAQs
- Help Guides
- Live Chat
- Mobile Application
- Phone
- Ticket
- Cash
- Check
- Major Credit Cards
- Cash
- Check
- Major Credit Cards
AutoNation vs. Carvana
Choosing the right dealership shapes your entire car-buying experience, from the selection you browse to the service you receive after signing. AutoNation and Carvana take very different approaches to helping you shop, which makes it easier to match your needs with the right one. If you want clarity before committing, keep reading to see which path fits your budget and buying style.
Vehicle selection and services
AutoNation gives you access to one of the largest networks of new and used cars in the country. They partner directly with major automakers, offering full lines of new vehicles along with certified pre-owned options backed by manufacturer warranties. Their used inventory is extensive and refreshed daily across their dealership network. AutoNation also provides financing assistance, trade-in evaluations, extended service contracts, and full-service maintenance through their repair centers, giving buyers a traditional dealership experience with all services in one place.
Carvana focuses on used vehicles only, offering thousands of options across various makes and models through their nationwide online catalog. They do not sell new cars or certified pre-owned models in the manufacturer-backed sense, but every vehicle goes through a 150-point inspection. Carvana supports financing through their platform, accepts trade-ins, and offers optional extended coverage plans. Since they don’t operate physical repair centers, ongoing service isn’t part of their model, but they do provide detailed vehicle history reports and fast at-home delivery or pickup through their vending machines.
Customer experience and convenience
AutoNation blends in-store support with growing digital tools. Buyers can browse inventory online, calculate payments, schedule service, and even start the purchase process before visiting in person. Their staff handles paperwork, test drives, and walk-throughs, which appeals to shoppers who want on-site guidance. AutoNation emphasizes transparency through upfront pricing and publishes vehicle history reports for used models. Their service centers also allow buyers to maintain their car without switching providers later.
Carvana builds the entire experience around convenience and self-service. Their website lets you complete everything digitally, from selecting the car to securing financing and arranging delivery. They provide 360-degree virtual tours and real-time availability, and their seven-day return policy remains one of their strongest selling points. The process limits human interaction unless needed through chat or phone support, which works well for shoppers who value speed and independence. Still, some buyers may miss the hands-on reassurance that test drives and in-person consultations provide.
Pricing and value
AutoNation follows a market-based pricing model that reflects current supply, demand, and manufacturer incentives. Their new car prices track official brand promotions, and they frequently run dealership-level offers or discounts on used inventory. Buyers can access multiple financing options through AutoNation’s lender network, which can help match different credit profiles. The added value comes from bundled services like warranty support, certified inspections, and on-site maintenance, though these perks may raise overall costs.
Carvana uses dynamic online pricing that updates in real time based on market conditions. Their vehicles usually fall in line with national used-car averages, and the all-digital model cuts out some traditional dealership fees. Financing is simple to compare because you can see several offers instantly, and their trade-in values are locked in for seven days. Carvana’s value lies in convenience, fast delivery, and clear upfront numbers, though buyers won’t get manufacturer-backed CPO warranties or ongoing service support.
Conclusion
AutoNation is a strong fit if you want a wide selection of new and certified used cars, in-person guidance, and a full-service ecosystem from purchase to maintenance. Carvana works better if you prefer a quick, fully digital buying experience with straightforward pricing and at-home delivery. Both models serve different needs, so choose the dealership that aligns with how you like to shop and what you expect after driving off with your car.