Car Dealership
Top Companies in 2025
AutoNation vs CarMax
Press [Add to Compare] to Edit, Add or Remove Vendors
- Straightforward pricing approach at many locations
- Strong online tools for financing, trade-ins, and vehicle browsing
- Multiple financing options through partnered lenders
- Wide nationwide network with extensive inventory variety
- Large service and maintenance network for long-term support
- Nationwide used car inventory with vehicle transfer service
- No-haggle, fixed-price purchasing model
- 24-hour test drive availability
- Streamlined online-to-in-store buying process
- Soft-credit-check pre-qualification financing
- 125+ point vehicle inspection and certification
- Multiple financing options
- 7-day guaranteed purchase offer for sellers
- Limited responsiveness to complaints or follow-up issues
- Reports of unexpected costs or add-on pressure during financing
- Customer experience varies significantly by location
- Lower ratings on major review platforms compared to competitors
- Premium pricing compared to traditional dealers
- No negotiation on vehicle prices
- Lower trade-in offers than private sale value
- Inconsistent post-sale customer service experience
- Potential for delayed title transfer
- Mixed reliability of online account systems
- Limited home delivery availability (60-mile radius)
AutoNation has grown into one of the largest automotive retailers in the United States since opening their first location in 1996 in Fort Lauderdale, Florida, where they remain headquartered. Their nationwide network spans hundreds of dealerships offering new and used vehicles, financing assistance, certified service centers, collision repair, trade-in options, and digital tools that let customers browse inventory, compare pricing, and start the buying process online. Their clear-pricing approach and broad selection attract shoppers looking for convenience and predictability, while their long-term service infrastructure supports drivers throughout ownership. Customer feedback varies widely across locations, with some praising attentive staff and smooth experiences, while others report communication issues, unresolved service concerns, or unexpected costs. They are not accredited by the Better Business Bureau and currently hold a rating of 1.32 out of 5, which reflects mixed satisfaction levels across their network. Despite the varied feedback, their scale, availability, and flexible shopping options make them a major player in the industry. Readers interested in how these strengths and limitations play out across different stages of the car-buying journey will find deeper insights throughout this full review.
Established in 1993, CarMax has grown into America's largest used car retailer by fundamentally reengineering the car-buying experience around transparency and convenience. The company's core offering is a massive nationwide inventory of over 50,000 vehicles available through a completely no-haggle, fixed-price model. This approach eliminates negotiation stress and creates a predictable purchasing process that can be completed online, in-store, or through a combination of both. CarMax enhances this with customer-friendly policies, including 24-hour test drives, a 10-day money-back guarantee, and a rigorous 125-point inspection on every vehicle. For financing, CarMax Auto Finance and partner lenders offer accessible options with soft-credit-check pre-qualification, serving a wide range of credit profiles. They also provide a standout selling experience with instant online offers and same-day payment, with no obligation to buy a car in return. While generally well-regarded for their transparent process and extensive selection, CarMax's convenience comes at a price premium compared to traditional dealerships, and some customers report inconsistent post-sale service experiences. The company maintains an A+ BBB rating and has been recognized for 21 consecutive years as a Fortune "100 Best Companies to Work For," cementing their reputation as an industry leader in ethical retail practices.
- Auto Loan Option : {"id":"Available"}
- Financing Options : Available
- Locations Served : 300+ locations across the United States
- Qualified Mechanics : Available
- Servicing Departments : Most locations include full-service departments; availability may vary by store
- Vehicle Types Inventory : {"id":"Both"}
- Auto Loan Option : Available
- Financing Options : Available
- Locations Served : 253 locations nationwide
- Qualified Mechanics : Not Available
- Servicing Departments : Service and repair departments are available at many locations
- Vehicle Types Inventory : Used
- One of the largest dealership networks in the United States
- Clear-pricing model that reduces negotiation stress
- Integrated online-to-store buying experience for flexible shopping
- Mobile service availability in select markets for added convenience
- 10-day money-back guarantee
- Sell-your-car service with no purchase obligation required
- MaxCare exclusionary extended service plan available
- Same-day payment for vehicle sales
- Fortune 100 Best Companies to Work For® (21 consecutive years)
- Free Experian AutoCheck reports on all inventory
- Non-commissioned sales staff guidance
- New Cars
- Used Cars
- New Cars—Undisclosed
- Used Cars
- FAQs
- Help Guides
- Live Chat
- Mobile Application
- Phone
- Ticket
- FAQs
- Help Guides
- Live Chat
- Mobile Application
- Phone
- Ticket—Undisclosed
- Cash
- Check
- Major Credit Cards
- Cash
- Check—Undisclosed
- Major Credit Cards
AutoNation vs. CarMax
Choosing between AutoNation and CarMax comes down to what kind of car-buying experience you want. Both are major players in the automotive world, and each brings something different to the table. If you want clarity, value, or a one-stop service center, understanding these differences helps you make a smarter decision. Keep reading to see which one fits your goals best.
Vehicle selection and services
AutoNation operates over 300 retail outlets across the United States, giving them a wide reach and access to a large mix of new and used vehicles. They offer certified pre-owned options along with financing, maintenance, collision repair, mobile service, and other support services. Their broad selection and full service capability appeal to buyers who want both variety and long-term dealership support in one place.
CarMax runs around 250 to 253 stores and focuses almost entirely on used vehicles. Their large sales volume allows them to maintain a wide used car inventory supported by uniform inspections and reconditioning. They do not specialize in new cars or long-term in-house servicing, but they excel at offering a consistent and predictable used car selection across their locations.
Customer experience and convenience
CarMax is known for a smooth and transparent buying experience that avoids negotiation. Their fixed pricing, upfront vehicle information, and easy ability to browse or purchase online or in-store create a predictable environment that many buyers appreciate. They also offer a 10-day return window and a limited warranty on many vehicles, which adds peace of mind.
AutoNation offers flexibility that varies by location. Since they operate a large network with different brands and service centers, buyers may encounter different experiences, but the advantage is access to new vehicles, certified used options, and bundled services such as maintenance and financing. Buyers who like handling everything in one place often find this approach convenient.
Pricing and value
CarMax keeps pricing standardized and transparent across their used inventory. Their pricing commonly starts in the lower range of about 13K to 15K for older or higher mileage vehicles. Mid-range cars often fall between 18K and 28K, depending on age, mileage, and model. Late model or higher-end used vehicles can reach 40K to 50K or more. Because they sell used cars only and use fixed pricing, their costs are predictable and easier for budgeting.
AutoNation offers a wider pricing spectrum since they sell both new and used vehicles. Their used and certified pre-owned models often overlap with CarMax pricing, ranging from the lower teens up to the 30K range, depending on condition and brand. Their new vehicles typically start around the mid 20K range for compact models and can reach 50K and above for SUVs, trucks, and premium brands. Their value often comes from incentives, dealer promotions, manufacturer discounts, and the ability to bundle financing or maintenance, which can lower the overall cost of ownership.
Conclusion
For a predictable and straightforward used car buying experience with no negotiation and clear pricing, CarMax is a strong choice. Their consistency, transparency, and large inventory make them ideal for buyers who want clarity and convenience.
For more options, such as new vehicles, certified used models, and long-term support available under one dealership group, AutoNation may be the better fit. Their extensive network and bundled services work well for buyers who want more flexibility and ongoing dealership support.