ADP TotalSource vs Paychex
Press [Add to Compare] to Edit, Add or Remove Vendors
- Excellent payroll services
- Automatic employee tracking
- Multiple packages for different business sizes
- Easy mobile app
- Employee self-service
- A+ rated and accredited by the BBB
- Financial Wellness Program
- Employee self-service options
- Excellent customer support options
- Mobile app
- Affordable prices and customizable plans
- Simple and up-to-date all-in-one software
- Interface may be confusing
- May be expensive
- Does not advertise prices
- May be charged extra for some necessary features
- Difficulties with custom reports & onboarding
- May require over 5 employees
ADP TotalSource (NASDAQ – ADP) provides a comprehensive cloud-based solution for employee life cycle management that spans HR administration, talent management, employee benefits, payroll, and regulatory compliance. They have over 60 years of experience and employ many professionals in HR, talent, and compliance, which they use to give you considerable purchasing power for premium advantages— without the premium costs. They offer four payroll options that serve all business sizes, with features that range from basic payroll, taxes, and compliance assistance all the way to a premium suite of tools that includes HR support, training, business advice, and legal assistance. Pricing information for these options is not advertised as it is tailored to company size and requirements, so you must fill out a form for a quote. They are a large PEO company that claims to have more than 80% of the Fortune 500 businesses as clients and around one million clients in 140 countries, and they accordingly employ over 60,000 associates to meet their clients' needs.
Paychex is a leading supplier of comprehensive human capital management systems for payroll, employee benefits, human resources, retirement plans, and business insurance services in the US and Northern Europe. Paychex, Inc. (NASDAQ: PAYX) was founded in 1971 and has more than 730,000 client companies, mostly small to medium-sized businesses but also larger businesses. They are considered one of the top companies in their field, claiming to pay 1 in 12 employees in the private sector. They offer three package categories tailored to fit a business's size and needs, with flexible payment options. They also boast easy-to-use online services and expert consultants that ensure proper federal and state compliance and can get you valuable tax credits and phone and online support. Paychex services vary according to the organization's needs and size, with a base monthly cost of $39 plus $5 per employee.
- Business Size : Small to medium-sized businesses (SMBs)
- Cost : Not advertised
- Customer Experience : Excellent
- IRS-Certified : True
- Expert HR Guidance : True
- BBB Rating : A+
- NAPEO Member : True
- ESAC Accreditation : True
- Business Size : Any
- Cost : Starts at $39 + $5 per employee/month
- Customer Experience : Excellent
- IRS-Certified : True
- Expert HR Guidance : True
- BBB Rating : A+
- Trustpilot Score : 1.2 out of 5
- NAPEO Member : True
- ESAC Accreditation : True
- Comprehensive HR, talent, and compliance
- Automatic employee tracking
- Powerful technology and data-driven insights
- Mobile app
- Online product demo
- AI-driven principles, such as for candidate relevancy
- A+ rated and accredited by the BBB
- Responsive expert guidance
- Comprehensive HR technologies & integrations
- Excellent customer support options
- Fully-featured PEO and HR solutions
- Large Businesses—Undisclosed
- Medium-Sized Businesses
- Small Businesses
- Large Businesses
- Medium-Sized Businesses
- Small Businesses
- 401(k)
- Accident
- COBRA Administration
- Critical Illness
- Disability
- Employee Self-Service
- HSA/FSA
- Medical, Dental, Vision
- Shopping & Entertainment Discounts
- Work-Life Employee Assistance Program
- 401(k)
- Accident
- COBRA Administration
- Critical Illness—Undisclosed
- Disability
- Employee Self-Service
- HSA/FSA
- Medical, Dental, Vision
- Shopping & Entertainment Discounts—Undisclosed
- Work-Life Employee Assistance Program—Undisclosed
- Onboarding
- Report Builder
- Risk Mitigation
- Time & Attendance
- Unemployment Insurance
- Workers' Compensation
- Workplace Compliance & Safety
- Onboarding
- Report Builder
- Risk Mitigation
- Time & Attendance
- Unemployment Insurance
- Workers' Compensation
- Workplace Compliance & Safety
- Direct Deposit
- Garnishments
- Global Payroll—Undisclosed
- Payroll History & Tracking
- Reimbursement Management
- Salary Revision & Raise Management
- Tax Services
- Time-Off Requests & Scheduling
- US Payroll
- Direct Deposit
- Garnishments
- Global Payroll—Undisclosed
- Payroll History & Tracking
- Reimbursement Management
- Salary Revision & Raise Management
- Tax Services
- Time-Off Requests & Scheduling
- US Payroll
- All-In-One Software Tool
- Cloud Analytics, Insights, & Reporting
- Customized Reports
- Global EOR Platform
- Third-Party Cloud Application Integration—Undisclosed
- Virtual Assistance
- All-In-One Software Tool
- Cloud Analytics, Insights, & Reporting
- Customized Reports
- Global EOR Platform—Undisclosed
- Third-Party Cloud Application Integration—Undisclosed
- Virtual Assistance
- Construction
- Consulting—Undisclosed
- E-Commerce—Undisclosed
- Education
- Engineering—Undisclosed
- Financial Services
- Food & Beverage
- Government
- Healthcare
- Hospitality
- Legal Services—Undisclosed
- Life Sciences—Undisclosed
- Manufacturing
- Marketing/Advertising—Undisclosed
- Media/Entertainment—Undisclosed
- Nonprofit/Social Services
- Professional/Technical Services
- Retail
- Technology—Undisclosed
- Construction
- Consulting—Undisclosed
- E-Commerce—Undisclosed
- Education—Undisclosed
- Engineering—Undisclosed
- Financial Services—Undisclosed
- Food & Beverage
- Government—Undisclosed
- Healthcare
- Hospitality
- Legal Services—Undisclosed
- Life Sciences—Undisclosed
- Manufacturing—Undisclosed
- Marketing/Advertising—Undisclosed
- Media/Entertainment—Undisclosed
- Nonprofit/Social Services—Undisclosed
- Professional/Technical Services
- Retail
- Technology—Undisclosed
- Comprehensive Resume Search & Service
- Early Access to Earned Pay
- Student Loan Repayment Program
- Talent Growth & Retention
- Third-Party HCM Integration
- Comprehensive Resume Search & Service—Undisclosed
- Early Access to Earned Pay—Undisclosed
- Student Loan Repayment Program—Undisclosed
- Talent Growth & Retention—Undisclosed
- Third-Party HCM Integration
- —Undisclosed
- FAQs
- Help Guides—Undisclosed
- Live Chat
- Mobile App
- Phone
- —Undisclosed
- FAQs
- Help Guides—Undisclosed
- Live Chat
- Mobile App
- Phone
ADP TotalSource vs. Paychex
When it comes to outsourcing critical HR and administrative functions, businesses often turn to Professional Employer Organizations (PEOs) to simplify their operations. ADP (Automatic Data Processing) and Paychex are two notable players in the PEO industry, offering a suite of services aimed at supporting businesses in managing their HR responsibilities. In this detailed comparison, we'll explore the key differences and strengths of ADP and Paychex as PEO service providers, empowering you to make an informed choice for your organization's HR needs.
Service Offerings
Both ADP and Paychex offer an extensive range of PEO services, encompassing HR administration, payroll management, employee benefits, and more. ADP's services are highly adaptable, enabling businesses to customize their PEO packages to suit specific requirements. Paychex, on the other hand, focuses on delivering comprehensive HR outsourcing plans, with a particular emphasis on serving small and midsize businesses (SMBs).
Scalability
ADP's PEO services cater to businesses of varying sizes, from startups to large corporations. This scalability ensures that the PEO solution can evolve in tandem with the client's business. Paychex primarily targets SMBs. If your company falls within the SMB category and seeks specialized PEO services, Paychex is well-positioned to address your needs.
Pricing
ADP's pricing model is known for its intricacy, taking into account several key factors that can influence your costs. These factors encompass your company's size, the specific services you require, and the payroll package you select. To obtain a pricing quote from ADP, you'll need to provide business details through their website. ADP's approach allows for customization, ensuring that your PEO solution aligns precisely with your business needs.
Paychex offers a variety of pricing plans dedicated to businesses of different sizes and requirements. One notable option they provide is the pay-as-you-go alternative. This pricing plan can be especially advantageous for smaller enterprises aiming to reduce upfront costs. Paychex's flexibility in pricing plans ensures that businesses, irrespective of their size, can find a suitable plan that aligns with their budget and needs.
Compliance & Risk Management
Both companies demonstrate expertise in navigating the intricate landscape of employment regulations and compliance matters. ADP and Paychex keep an eye out for changes in labor laws and regulations, assisting clients in mitigating legal risks and maintaining compliance.
Employee Benefits
ADP and Paychex offer comprehensive employee benefits packages, encompassing matters like health insurance and retirement plans. Specific offerings and customization options may vary, necessitating discussions with each provider to align the benefits package with the client's unique requirements.
Technology & Integration
ADP is recognized for its user-friendly technological solutions, including a robust HR platform and mobile application for convenient access to HR and payroll information. They also facilitate integration with a variety of accounting and HR software.
Paychex also delivers a user-friendly platform that is well-received, particularly among SMBs. They provide online tools and resources to streamline HR processes and ensure seamless integration with other software.
Customer Support
Both ADP and Paychex maintain dedicated customer support teams to address inquiries and resolve issues. Paychex distinguishes itself by offering 24/7 support, ensuring assistance is available around the clock.
In summary, ADP and Paychex are reputable PEO service providers, each endowed with distinctive strengths and areas of specialization. When contemplating a choice between them, businesses should evaluate the size of their operations, specific PEO needs, budget considerations, and individual preferences. Conducting thorough research and engaging in personalized discussions with their sales teams will facilitate well-informed decision-making that matches the organization's objectives and demands.
Save Big on PEO
Fill out a quick form to claim special offers on PEO
