Payroll Solutions Providers
Top Companies in 2024
ADP Payroll vs Deluxe Payroll
Press [Add to Compare] to Edit, Add or Remove Vendors
- Proprietary mobile app
- Multi-platform self-service portal
- Promotions for small businesses
- Serve all business sizes in many industries
- Two product demo options available
- Scalability through multiple levels of products
- Workflow automation
- Learning management system
- Automatic tax filing for 50 states
- No free trial for medium and large companies
- Many features considered add-ons
- No pricing transparency
- HR assist tools and guidance as an optional add-on
- No demo or free trial
- Leaving the US payroll market
- May be pricey
- Limited customizations with a high learning curve
ADP is a human capital management (HCM) solutions provider, utilizing a cloud-based interface for their services that include payroll as well as management of businesses' HR, talent, time, taxes, and benefits. They were founded in 1949 and are based in Roseland, NJ, and offer businesses of all sizes the ability to streamline their payroll processes. They serve many industries such as restaurants, retail, healthcare, financial services, non-profit, construction, services, and the government/education sector. Their services include direct deposit and mobile payroll solutions that integrate with time and attendance tracking, automatically calculating deductions for taxes and retirement contributions, and providing expert support to ensure business compliance. They have many plans listed on their website depending on business size, four for small businesses and three for middle to large-sized businesses. However, clients must submit for a personalized pricing quote. They have received many industry accolades such being named "Global Payroll Supplier of the Year" in 2022 and were in Fortune World's Most Admired Companies list for the past 17 years. They are BBB-accredited with an A+ rating there but have received many complaints there. They have a 1.3 out of 5 Trustpilot score due to clients having trouble logging in or accessing ADP's services, among other things.
Deluxe Corporation, founded in 1915 and based in Minneapolis, MN, is a company that provides payments and data solutions. They have a long history of developing cutting-edge payment solutions. However, they will be discontinuing payroll processing and associated HR services in the United States on March 15, 2024, while continuing to offer them in Canada. They offer a wide range of services, including digital payment exchange, merchant services, and promotional solutions. Deluxe Corporation has a people-centric approach and invests heavily in their employees' development and well-being. Deluxe, as a company, values individuality and promotes an inclusive workplace. They encourage their employees to volunteer for community organizations and have awarded over $110 million in grants via their foundation, while their employees have a long history of donating their time and money to non-profits. The company has an A+ rating from BBB, and their payroll services have received mostly positive customer feedback.
- Free Trial : 3 months (smaller businesses only)
- Pricing Option : Per-employee/ Per-payroll
- Transparent Pricing : Unavailable
- Pricing : Undisclosed
- Trustpilot Score : 1.3 out of 5
- BBB Rating : A+
- Free Trial : N/A
- Pricing Option : Monthly, per employee per month
- Transparent Pricing : Unavailable for Canadian clients
- Pricing : Starts at $45 per month plus $7 per employee per month
- Trustpilot Score : N/R
- BBB Rating : A+
- State & federal forms and tax filing
- Computer, mobile app, phone call support
- Flexible options & robust reporting
- Three months of free payroll for small businesses
- Streamlined payroll processes
- Learning management system
- Stringent security measures
- 401K Tracking
- API/Integration Capabilities
- Direct Deposit
- FMLA Tracking—Undisclosed
- Generation of Pay Stubs & Reports
- Mobile App for Employees
- Multi-Country
- Multi-State
- 401K Tracking
- API/Integration Capabilities
- Direct Deposit
- FMLA Tracking
- Generation of Pay Stubs & Reports
- Mobile App for Employees
- Multi-Country—Undisclosed
- Multi-State
- Compliance With State & Federal Tax Laws
- Form 1099-Misc
- Form W-2
- Form W-3
- Form W-4
- Tax Filing
- Compliance With State & Federal Tax Laws
- Form 1099-Misc
- Form W-2
- Form W-3
- Form W-4
- Tax Filing
- Documentation
- FMLA Training—Undisclosed
- Live Online
- Videos
- Documentation
- FMLA Training
- Live Online
- Videos—Undisclosed
- Calculate & Pay Employee Salaries
- Real-Time Reports
- Time, Attendance & Overtime Tracking
- Update Real-Time Employee Information
- Calculate & Pay Employee Salaries
- Real-Time Reports
- Time, Attendance & Overtime Tracking
- Update Real-Time Employee Information
- Android
- Cloud-Based
- iOS
- Mac
- Windows
- Android
- Cloud-Based
- iOS
- Mac
- Windows
- Large Businesses
- Medium-Sized Businesses
- Small Businesses
- Large Businesses
- Medium-Sized Businesses
- Small Businesses
- Blog
- Demos
- —Undisclosed
- FAQs
- Help Guides
- Live Chat
- Mobile App
- Phone
- Blog—Undisclosed
- Demos
- FAQs
- Help Guides
- Live Chat—Undisclosed
- Mobile App
- Phone
Save Big on Payroll
Fill out a quick form to claim special offers on Payroll