Shopify POS vs Square POS

Square vs. Shopify POS

Published: June 11, 2024

Business success requires understanding clients' needs and implementing strategies to increase their satisfaction. Point-of-sale (POS) systems are critical in business operations, particularly in elevating customer service, efficiency, and handling finances. Square and Shopify POS offer competitive features that can make or break your business. This comparison aims to evaluate each company’s services, ease of use, security, and pricing. Continue reading to discover which POS system is more suitable for your business needs.

Service range and customization options

Shopify and Square point-of-sale systems mainly support small and medium enterprises. Both POS systems accommodate several payment methods, such as mobile payments and debit and credit cards, gift cards, and mobile wallets, with flexible tax settings based on regional tax laws and product-specific rules while ensuring proper reporting and analytics to guide businesses in practical decisions. Business users can personalize their receipts with logos, business details, and custom messages, and digital receipt options can be offered via email or SMS. Square and Shopify POS also provide invoicing capabilities whereby businesses can transmit and track invoices directly from the POS system and facilitate payment billing. The Invoices can be branded and detailed with products and personalized messages. Additionally, both platforms offer various hardware options to facilitate seamless in-person transactions. 

The most significant difference between Shopify POS and Square POS regarding the range of services and customizability is the level of integration with third-party providers. Shopify does excellent work with integration on their formidable e-commerce platform due to their live chat and virtual assistant features, enabling businesses to run online and offline sales routes. The company integrates with hundreds of third-party applications that allow users to get custom solutions such as subscription billing and advanced appointment scheduling. On the other hand, Square POS offers a user-friendly interface with built-in features like Square Appointments, providing transparent and competitive payment processing.

Ease of use and integration

Shopify and Square POS have robust and easy-to-learn systems and are well-integrated with their respective platforms. They both feature interfaces designed for the most straightforward setup and daily operations possible for the user. Third-party app integrations are also available to extend functionality within various applications. Square and Shopify POS can be integrated with popular accounting programs, ensuring smooth financial management. When it comes to payment processing, both systems are flexible enough to accept any payment method, thereby enhancing the check-out process for customers.

However, the two POS systems vary in their ease of utility regarding the learning needs of new users. Shopify POS offers a seamless experience for businesses already using the Shopify ecosystem, efficiently managing sales, inventory, and customer information. While they feature a clean and user-friendly interface, new users may encounter a steep learning curve. In contrast, Square POS is designed to ease operations, learning, and setup, which suits businesses with high staff turnover rates. Lastly, the company integrates seamlessly with their own payment system, providing fast and hassle-free operations.

Security and compliance

Shopify and Square POS are security- and compliance-focused in their respective platforms, rich with security features that protect transactions and secure sensitive customer data. Both companies use encryption protocols that guarantee data confidentiality and integrity between a POS system and its servers. They also use modern fraud detection mechanisms, including machine learning, to identify and prevent fraudulent transactions. Security-wise, what distinguishes these POS systems are the additional features offered, particularly those involving third-party integrations.

Pricing

The standard pricing features of Square and Shopify POS include support for multiple payment methods, such as mobile wallets and contactless payments, detailed reporting and analytics, and customer management tools to track financial history and manage loyalty programs.

The main differences lie in the pricing structure of the two products. Shopify POS charges a monthly fee for different functionality levels. Subscription prices start at $39 for the Basic plan, with an additional $89 per location for Shopify POS Pro. Additionally, transaction fees apply and vary based on the plan tier. Square POS offers a free basic package with no monthly charges, making it appealing to small businesses and startups. However, more advanced plans can cost $60 or $153 monthly per location. Square charges a fixed rate of 2.6% + 10¢ per card-present transaction and 2.9% + 30¢ for card-not-present transactions. While Square's actual per-transaction charges will run slightly higher, the lack of a monthly fee with its basic POS and inexpensive hardware options make it cost-effective for merchants with lower transaction volumes.

Conclusion

Shopify and Square POS put a premium on simplicity, integration, and robust security features. The platforms offer tools for managing inventory and monitoring sales, thus allowing the business to operate flexibly and efficiently daily. Shopify POS's deep integration with the Shopify e-commerce platform seems to shine, offering much customization for companies already using Shopify for online sales. On the contrary, Square POS is a simple, all-in-one solution that doesn't require any monthly fees from the user, making them appealing for small businesses to look into. The POS systems prioritize user information safety as they work under PCI DSS guidelines, deploying encryption protocols and mechanisms to protect against fraud on transactions and customer data. Ultimately, the final choice between Shopify and Square POS depends on the nature of the business. 

Get Your Free POS Quote Now