No Cinnamon After the Recall? Try These Flavorful Herb Combos!

1. Ginger and nutmeg: The sweet and subtle blend

Ginger brings some spicy warmth, while nutmeg has a mellow sweetness and a slight earthiness. Together, they create a blend that echoes cinnamon’s complexity without overpowering your dish. For recipes like apple pie or pumpkin bread, try using a 1:1 mix of ginger and nutmeg to mimic that familiar flavor. Start with half the amount the recipe calls for in cinnamon, then taste and adjust. This combo is perfect for baked goods where you want a cozy yet balanced flavor.

2. Allspice and cardamom: A bit Bold, a bit sweet

Allspice is known for its bold and slightly peppery notes, while cardamom has a sweet, citrusy warmth that adds depth. When combined, they create a layered, spicy-sweet flavor profile that’s reminiscent of cinnamon but with a little more zing. For quick breads or muffins, try using ¾ teaspoon of allspice to ¼ teaspoon of cardamom as a starting point. This mix works particularly well in recipes with vanilla or chocolate, enhancing the richness without overpowering the other flavors.

3. Cloves and nutmeg: Rich and cozy

Cloves are known for their potent, almost menthol-like intensity, but when paired with the creamy sweetness of nutmeg, they offer a rich, warm backdrop to any baked dish. Cloves can be strong, so a little goes a long way! Try starting with ⅛ teaspoon of cloves to ½ teaspoon of nutmeg. This duo shines in classic holiday desserts, like gingerbread or spiced cookies, giving you that familiar holiday warmth even without cinnamon.

4. Anise and allspice: Earthy and slightly sweet

Anise brings an herbal, licorice-like note to the mix, while allspice provides a warm spiciness that pairs beautifully with anise’s subtle sweetness. Use a small pinch of anise (it’s potent!) with ¼ to ½ teaspoon of allspice to start. This combination works wonders in fruit-based desserts, like poached pears or spiced apple compote, adding complexity that enhances natural sweetness. Anise’s unique flavor can elevate your dish with an unexpected twist that mimics the aromatic profile of cinnamon in a new way.

5. Cardamom and ginger: Warmth with a hint of citrus

Cardamom’s slight citrusy notes paired with ginger’s peppery warmth create a lively, fragrant duo. This combination brings out the best in recipes with a bit of natural sweetness, like banana bread or carrot cake. Start with equal parts cardamom and ginger, using about half the amount called for in cinnamon, and taste as you go. The result? A warm, rounded spice blend that captures the spirit of cinnamon but with an extra layer of brightness.

6. Nutmeg, allspice, and cloves: The ultimate cozy blend

If you’re looking to replicate the full-bodied spice of cinnamon, try a small blend of nutmeg, allspice, and a hint of cloves. Nutmeg provides the warmth, allspice brings sweetness, and cloves add depth. Mix ½ teaspoon nutmeg, ¼ teaspoon allspice, and a tiny pinch of cloves. This blend is especially delightful in cinnamon rolls or spiced lattes, offering a depth of flavor that’s both comforting and complex.

Tips for Perfecting Your Cinnamon-Free Baking

When using these spice blends, remember that each of these herbs has its own unique intensity. Start with less, and adjust as you go, especially with potent ones like cloves or anise. Not only will you end up with a delicious result, but you’ll also have the chance to experiment with flavors you might not have thought to pair with your usual cinnamon.

Baking without cinnamon doesn’t have to mean sacrificing flavor. By combining these herbs and spices thoughtfully, you can create the same warmth and coziness that cinnamon brings to your favorite recipes. 

Save 50% on Your First Green Chef Meal Kit—Sign Up Today!