Elio: A Rocky Journey from Theatrical Bomb to Digital Release

Behind the scenes: A "catastrophic" path to theaters

Elio's troubles began long before its theatrical release. Originally envisioned by openly gay director Adrian Molina (co-director of Pixar's Oscar-winning Coco), the film initially featured a queer-coded protagonist with scenes suggesting environmental consciousness and non-traditional interests. Early sequences showed Elio creating fashion from trash ("trash-ion show") and bedroom decorations hinting at male crushes.

According to numerous insiders, Pixar leadership gradually sanded down these character nuances, making Elio more conventionally masculine and stripping away much of what made the character distinctive.

The production turmoil escalated when Molina screened his cut to Pixar leadership in summer 2023. After what sources describe as a difficult feedback session with Pixar chief Pete Docter, Molina exited the project, and directors Madeline Sharafian and Domee Shi (Turning Red) took over. This resulted in what one source called an "exodus of talent" as creatives dissatisfied with the new direction departed the project. This included the recasting of Elio's mother's character. America Ferrera originally voiced Olga, Elio's mother, but left the project to be replaced by Zoe Saldaña, with the character reimagined as Elio's aunt rather than mother.

Identity crisis: From queer coding to ambiguous representation

The transformation of Elio's character from queer-coded to vaguely neurodivergent represents what many see as Pixar's ongoing struggle with representation. The film's attempt to reframe Elio as potentially autistic rather than queer feels less like authentic representation and more like corporate caution in the wake of Disney's recent controversies. After Lightyear's same-gender kiss sparked conservative backlash and contributed to its box office underperformance, followed by similar controversies in Marvel productions, Pixar leadership appears to have retreated from LGBTQ+ representation.

This strategic withdrawal continued a pattern evident in other projects, such as the Pixar series Win or Lose, which previously created controversy over its scrapped transgender storyline. The result in Elio is a protagonist whose distinctive traits feel watered down to harmless eccentricities rather than meaningful characterization.

Box office bomb: Perfect storm of problems

Elio's theatrical failure cannot be attributed to any single factor but rather a convergence of multiple issues:

• Fierce competition: The film opened against established franchises like How to Train Your Dragon (which grossed $37 million in its second weekend during Elio's debut) and the live-action Lilo & Stitch remake, which was in its fifth week but still pulling in nearly $10 million. Family audiences faced multiple choices, and Elio, lacking built-in recognition, lost out
• Marketing missteps: The film's promotional campaign failed to articulate a compelling reason for audiences to choose it over competitors. As one industry observer noted: "A boy with a patch and goofy aliens just isn't cutting it". Additionally, the title itself may have caused confusion, sounding suspiciously similar to Pixar's earlier Luca
• Production delays: Originally scheduled for March 2024, Elio's release was pushed to June 2025, creating speculation about production problems
• Audience skepticism: Social media impressions revealed an overall negative perception of Elio due to past disappointments from Disney and Pixar. Comments included: "Looks like a fun movie, but Pixar's quality really seems to be diminishing," and "Pixar is dead. This looks absolutely atrocious."

Narrative shortcomings: A compromised vision

Beyond production controversies, Elio suffers from structural storytelling problems that likely stem from its fractured development process. The film follows Elio, a lonely boy who is mistakenly identified as Earth's leader and beamed into space, where he must navigate an intergalactic community called the Communiverse.

While visually dazzling with impressively imaginative alien designs, the narrative struggles with coherence and emotional depth. The earth-bound opening acts feel underdeveloped, failing to establish the profound connection between Elio and his parents, whose off-screen death serves as the traumatic inciting incident. Unlike Pixar classics like Up—which masterfully established Carl and Ellie's relationship in its iconic opening sequence—Elio seldom earns its emotional beats.

The film's middle section meanders through overstuffed set pieces without clear narrative momentum. As the BBC noted: "There are too many scenes before Elio leaves Earth and reaches a psychedelic alien craft called the Communiverse. And then the film packs Elio off to a villain's spaceship. And then he's back in the Communiverse. And then he's on Earth. And then he's in the Communiverse again".

These structural issues reflect what some critics have identified as a growing problem at Pixar: their nervousness about letting their creatives tell a fun, simple story. With multiple directors and three credited screenwriters, Elio becomes a Frankenstein’s Monster of various plot points rather than a cohesive whole.

Digital afterlife: Second chance or final resting place?

Elio's digital release offers the film a potential path to redemption, or at least profitability. Previous Pixar films like Elemental demonstrated strong post-theatrical performance, eventually turning a profit through streaming despite a slow theatrical start. With an A CinemaScore and generally positive critical reception, Elio has the elements for streaming success. Also, the lower financial barrier of digital rental might encourage sampling by curious viewers. 

However, the film faces significant challenges in the crowded digital marketplace. Without the cultural buzz that propelled films like KPop Demon Hunters to Netflix's number one movie, with its catchy original music inspiring repeated listening and discussion, Elio lacks elements that encourage ongoing engagement beyond the viewing experience itself.

Is this a cautionary tale for modern animation?

Elio represents both Pixar's enduring strengths and its current creative struggles. The film's visual imagination, heartfelt messaging about difference and connection, and emotional ambition remind viewers why Pixar once dominated animation. Yet its narrative inconsistencies, compromised character development, and lack of clear identity reflect a studio struggling to balance artistic vision with corporate caution.

As the animation landscape evolves, with Sony finding success with innovative projects like Spider-Verse and KPop Demon Hunters, Pixar faces increasing pressure to redefine its creative identity. The solution may lie in trusting distinctive directorial visions rather than sanding them down into harmless but unremarkable entertainment.

For Elio, the digital release represents not just a second chance at finding an audience, but a test case for whether compromised films can achieve redemption in the streaming era. Its performance on Disney+ may ultimately determine whether Pixar embraces more daring storytelling or retreats further into safe, familiar territory.

Unlock Streaming Worldwide With a VPN!