Auto Loans
Top Companies in 2025
LightStream vs MyAutoLoan
Press [Add to Compare] to Edit, Add or Remove Vendors
- Loan Experience Guarantee
- A wide range of loans offered
- No extra fees
- Nationwide services
- Variety of auto financing options
- Loan calculator
- Lack of transparency
- No Guaranteed Auto Protection (GAP
- Limited availability
- Eligibility and loan restrictions
- Transparency concerns
LightStream, a division of SunTrust Bank, was founded in 2014 and is headquartered in Atlanta, Georgia. It provides unsecured auto loans, allowing borrowers to finance new and used vehicles, refinance existing loans, or purchase motorcycles and boats, with loan amounts ranging from $5,000 to $100,000. The company is noted for their competitive interest rates, starting at 7.24% with autopay, and offers flexible loan terms from 24 to 84 months. Unique features include a rapid funding process that can deliver funds on the same day as application approval and a "Loan Experience Guarantee," which promises $100 to dissatisfied customers. Customer feedback highlights an easy online application process and the advantage of negotiating as a cash buyer, although borrowers with average or lower credit may face higher rates. LightStream has received a solid 4.3 out of 5 stars in reviews, reflecting a mix of strong rates and some customer service concerns. The company is also committed to environmental sustainability, planting a tree for every loan funded, which adds an appealing ethical dimension to their services. With an A+ rating from the Better Business Bureau, LightStream is a reputable choice in the auto loan market, particularly for those with good credit.
myAutoloan, founded in 2003 and headquartered in the United States, is an innovative online marketplace for auto financing. The platform connects borrowers with a network of lenders, enabling them to receive up to four competitive loan offers for new and used vehicles, refinancing, and lease buyouts. Unique features include a fast application process that typically takes just two minutes and the ability to prequalify with a soft credit pull, which protects users' credit scores. With a minimum credit score requirement of 600, myAutoloan caters to many borrowers, including those with lower credit ratings. The company has received positive feedback, as evidenced by its strong Trustpilot ratings and an A+ rating from the Better Business Bureau. Customers appreciate the ease of use and quick funding; they often receive loan decisions within minutes and funds as soon as the next business day. However, some users have raised concerns about hard credit checks impacting their scores and the lack of direct customer support via phone. Overall, myAutoloan stands out for their comprehensive approach to auto financing, combining convenience, transparency, and various options tailored to meet diverse consumer needs.
- Loan Terms : Up to 84 months
- Minimum Accepted Credit Score : 660 minimum credit score
- APR : 3.49%
- BBB Rating : A
- Loan Terms : Undisclosed
- Minimum Accepted Credit Score : Undisclosed
- APR : Undisclosed
- BBB Rating : A+
- No restrictions on mileage, car model or make
- Cash deposit as soon as the same day
- Online auto loan application process
- Multiple auto loan solutions
- Discounts
- Lease Buyout—Undisclosed
- Loan Refinancing
- New Vehicle
- Private Party—Undisclosed
- Used Vehicle
- Lease Buyout
- Loan Refinancing
- New Vehicle
- Private Party
- Used Vehicle
- Extended Warranty
- GAP Insurance
- Limited Warranty—Undisclosed
- Mobile Application—Undisclosed
- Online Account Management—Undisclosed
- Return Policy—Undisclosed
- Extended Warranty—Undisclosed
- GAP Insurance—Undisclosed
- Limited Warranty—Undisclosed
- Mobile Application—Undisclosed
- Online Account Management—Undisclosed
- Return Policy—Undisclosed
- Hard Credit Check—Undisclosed
- Income—Undisclosed
- Minimum Credit Score
- Pre-qualification With Soft Check
- Hard Credit Check
- Income—Undisclosed
- Minimum Credit Score
- Pre-qualification With Soft Check—Undisclosed
- Documentation/Processing Fee—Undisclosed
- Late Payment Fees—Undisclosed
- Origination Fee—Undisclosed
- Prepayment Penalties—Undisclosed
- Title Transfer Fee—Undisclosed
- Upfront or Application Fees
- Documentation/Processing Fee—Undisclosed
- Late Payment Fees—Undisclosed
- Origination Fee—Undisclosed
- Prepayment Penalties—Undisclosed
- Title Transfer Fee—Undisclosed
- Upfront or Application Fees—Undisclosed
- Automatic Payments
- Cash—Undisclosed
- Check—Undisclosed
- Debit or Credit Cards—Undisclosed
- In-Person Payments—Undisclosed
- Mail-In Payments
- Online Payments
- Phone Payments—Undisclosed
- Automatic Payments
- Cash—Undisclosed
- Check—Undisclosed
- Debit or Credit Cards
- In-Person Payments—Undisclosed
- Mail-In Payments—Undisclosed
- Online Payments
- Phone Payments—Undisclosed
- Articles and Videos
- FAQs
- Help Guides
- Live Chat
- Phone
- Articles and Videos
- FAQs
- Help Guides—Undisclosed
- Live Chat—Undisclosed
- Phone
LightStream vs. MyAutoLoan
When comparing LightStream and MyAutoLoan, two prominent auto loan providers, it’s crucial to evaluate their offerings, pricing, and user experiences to identify the best option for different borrower needs. While LightStream focuses on offering a seamless online experience for borrowers with strong credit, MyAutoLoan connects consumers with multiple lenders, catering to a broader range of credit profiles.
Service range and offerings
LightStream offers a wide array of auto loan options, including loans for new and used vehicle purchases, refinancing, private-party sales, lease buyouts, and even motorcycle financing. They stand out for their fully online application process, quick approvals, and same-day funding.
Additionally, LightStream does not charge fees or prepayment penalties, making their loans straightforward and predictable. However, their services are most beneficial to borrowers with excellent credit scores, as they do not provide prequalification options, which may discourage those uncertain about their eligibility.
MyAutoLoan, in contrast, operates as an auto loan marketplace. They enable borrowers to submit a single application and receive offers from up to four lenders, increasing the chances of finding favorable terms. MyAutoLoan supports various financing needs, including loans for new and used cars, refinancing, lease buyouts, and private-party purchases. They also allow prequalification with a soft credit check, making them a convenient option for borrowers unsure of their creditworthiness. However, their platform is not available in Alaska or Hawaii, limiting access for some users.
Pricing and fees
LightStream offers competitive rates, with APRs starting around 7% for qualified borrowers, depending on loan type and credit profile. Their Rate Beat Program further distinguishes them by pledging to beat a competitor’s rate by 0.10% under certain conditions. LightStream’s no-fee structure is another advantage, as they do not charge application fees, origination fees, or prepayment penalties. However, their lack of prequalification means borrowers must complete a full application to view potential rates, which involves a hard credit check.
MyAutoLoan does not charge borrowers to use their platform. Instead, they connect users with lenders who offer a range of rates and terms. Minimum loan amounts start at $8,000 for purchases and $5,000 for refinancing, and borrowers must meet specific income and credit score requirements. Rates and fees vary by lender, and while borrowers benefit from the ability to compare multiple offers, the final terms depend on the selected lender’s policies, which can introduce variability in costs.
Advantages and disadvantages
LightStream advantages:
• Fully online application process with same-day funding
• No fees or prepayment penalties
• Broad range of loan options, including motorcycle loans
• Nationwide availability
LightStream disadvantages:
• No prequalification process
• Requires excellent credit for competitive rates
• Lacks additional features like Guaranteed Auto Protection (GAP)
MyAutoLoan advantages:
• Marketplace approach increases chances of finding favorable terms
• Supports a broader range of credit profiles, including those with fair credit
• Offers prequalification with a soft credit check
• Access to multiple lenders through a single application
MyAutoLoan disadvantages:
• Not a direct lender, leading to variability in terms, and experience
• Services unavailable in Alaska and Hawaii
• Transparency concerns due to reliance on third-party lenders
Conclusion
Both LightStream and MyAutoLoan offer compelling auto loan solutions, but they cater to different audiences. LightStream is ideal for borrowers with excellent credit who value a fee-free, fully online experience with predictable loan terms. On the other hand, MyAutoLoan appeals to a broader range of borrowers, especially those seeking prequalification or comparing multiple lenders to secure the best deal. Understanding your credit profile, financial needs, and preferences will help determine which provider aligns best with your goals.