Auto Loans
Top Companies in 2024
Caribou vs LightStream
Press [Add to Compare] to Edit, Add or Remove Vendors
- Significant savings
- No hidden fees
- Quick and easy process
- Diverse lender network
- Loan Experience Guarantee
- A wide range of loans offered
- No extra fees
- Nationwide services
- Eligibility limitations
- Limited vehicle types
- Credit impact during final application
- Processing fee
- Lack of transparency
- No Guaranteed Auto Protection (GAP
Caribou Auto Refinance, founded in 2016, is a lending platform headquartered in Denver and Washington, D.C., that specializes in connecting borrowers with competitive auto refinancing options. The company partners with a network of lenders, primarily credit unions and community banks, to offer refinancing solutions tailored to individual needs. Caribou's online platform allows for a quick and easy application process, often completed within minutes. Key features of Caribou's services include prequalification without a hard credit check, the option to apply with a co-borrower, and access to additional products like guaranteed asset protection (GAP) insurance and key replacement programs. Caribou has an A+ rating from the Better Business Bureau and a 4.5-star rating on Trustpilot, indicating strong customer satisfaction. The company's financial stability is bolstered by significant backing from industry heavy hitters like Goldman Sachs and QED Investors. Despite a $399 processing fee, Caribou's services are designed to provide long-term savings through lower interest rates and flexible loan terms. For those seeking to refinance their auto loans, Caribou offers a seamless and potentially cost-effective solution, making it worth exploring further.
LightStream, a division of SunTrust Bank, was founded in 2014 and is headquartered in Atlanta, Georgia. It provides unsecured auto loans, allowing borrowers to finance new and used vehicles, refinance existing loans, or purchase motorcycles and boats, with loan amounts ranging from $5,000 to $100,000. The company is noted for their competitive interest rates, starting at 7.24% with autopay, and offers flexible loan terms from 24 to 84 months. Unique features include a rapid funding process that can deliver funds on the same day as application approval and a "Loan Experience Guarantee," which promises $100 to dissatisfied customers. Customer feedback highlights an easy online application process and the advantage of negotiating as a cash buyer, although borrowers with average or lower credit may face higher rates. LightStream has received a solid 4.3 out of 5 stars in reviews, reflecting a mix of strong rates and some customer service concerns. The company is also committed to environmental sustainability, planting a tree for every loan funded, which adds an appealing ethical dimension to their services. With an A+ rating from the Better Business Bureau, LightStream is a reputable choice in the auto loan market, particularly for those with good credit.
- Loan Terms : Undisclosed
- Minimum Accepted Credit Score : Undisclosed
- APR : Undisclosed
- BBB Rating : A+
- Loan Terms : Up to 84 months
- Minimum Accepted Credit Score : 660 minimum credit score
- APR : 3.49%
- BBB Rating : A
- Pre-qualification without credit impact
- No SSN required for rate check
- Wide range of protection services
- No restrictions on mileage, car model or make
- Cash deposit as soon as the same day
- Online auto loan application process
- Lease Buyout—Undisclosed
- Loan Refinancing—Undisclosed
- New Vehicle—Undisclosed
- Private Party—Undisclosed
- Used Vehicle—Undisclosed
- Lease Buyout—Undisclosed
- Loan Refinancing
- New Vehicle
- Private Party—Undisclosed
- Used Vehicle
- Extended Warranty—Undisclosed
- GAP Insurance
- Limited Warranty
- Mobile Application
- Online Account Management—Undisclosed
- Return Policy—Undisclosed
- Extended Warranty
- GAP Insurance
- Limited Warranty—Undisclosed
- Mobile Application—Undisclosed
- Online Account Management—Undisclosed
- Return Policy—Undisclosed
- Hard Credit Check—Undisclosed
- Income
- Minimum Credit Score
- Pre-qualification With Soft Check—Undisclosed
- Hard Credit Check—Undisclosed
- Income—Undisclosed
- Minimum Credit Score
- Pre-qualification With Soft Check
- Documentation/Processing Fee
- Late Payment Fees—Undisclosed
- Origination Fee
- Prepayment Penalties—Undisclosed
- Title Transfer Fee—Undisclosed
- Upfront or Application Fees
- Documentation/Processing Fee—Undisclosed
- Late Payment Fees—Undisclosed
- Origination Fee—Undisclosed
- Prepayment Penalties—Undisclosed
- Title Transfer Fee—Undisclosed
- Upfront or Application Fees
- Automatic Payments—Undisclosed
- Cash—Undisclosed
- Check—Undisclosed
- Debit or Credit Cards—Undisclosed
- In-Person Payments
- Mail-In Payments—Undisclosed
- Online Payments
- Phone Payments—Undisclosed
- Automatic Payments
- Cash—Undisclosed
- Check—Undisclosed
- Debit or Credit Cards—Undisclosed
- In-Person Payments—Undisclosed
- Mail-In Payments
- Online Payments
- Phone Payments—Undisclosed
- Articles and Videos
- FAQs
- Help Guides
- Live Chat
- Phone
- Articles and Videos
- FAQs
- Help Guides
- Live Chat
- Phone
Caribou vs. LightStream
When comparing Caribou and LightStream in the auto financing sector, both companies take different approaches tailored to specific borrower needs. Caribou focuses on auto loan refinancing, while LightStream provides a broader range of auto loan products, including financing for new and used vehicles, refinancing, and lease buyouts. To understand how these companies stack up, let’s explore their service range, pricing, and advantages.
Service range and offerings
Caribou specializes in refinancing auto loans, connecting borrowers with a network of lenders to help lower monthly payments, reduce interest rates, or adjust loan terms. Beyond refinancing, Caribou offers services like extended vehicle protection, title and registration assistance, and key replacement coverage. These added features make Caribou an appealing option for those looking to manage their car ownership more comprehensively. However, Caribou does not provide loans for new or used car purchases or lease buyouts, limiting its scope.
LightStream offers a wider range of loan products, including financing for new and used vehicles, private-party transactions, refinancing, and lease buyouts. Their loans are unsecured, meaning no collateral is required, which can be an attractive feature for borrowers with strong credit profiles. LightStream also provides same-day funding for approved loans and operates a completely paperless, online application process. However, unlike Caribou, LightStream does not include supplementary services such as title assistance or vehicle protection plans, focusing instead on delivering core loan options.
Pricing and fees
Caribou charges a $499 processing fee, which is often included in the refinanced loan amount. This fee covers administrative tasks such as document processing and vehicle retitling. While Caribou does not charge upfront fees for rate checks or prequalification, borrowers should carefully review the lender’s terms to understand the total cost of refinancing.
LightStream takes a different approach with its no-fee structure, eliminating application, origination, or prepayment penalties. Borrowers pay only their loan’s agreed-upon principal and interest, offering a transparent and straightforward borrowing experience. However, unlike Caribou, LightStream does not offer prequalification, requiring borrowers to undergo a hard credit inquiry to view their rates. This can temporarily affect a borrower’s credit score, which may deter those who prefer to shop around without impacting their credit.
Advantages and disadvantages
Caribou’s advantages lie in its specialization in refinancing, combined with supplementary services like extended warranties, key replacement, and title assistance. These added features make it an excellent choice for borrowers looking to improve their loan terms while addressing other aspects of car ownership. However, the $499 processing fee, limited loan options, and eligibility restrictions for certain vehicle types can be drawbacks for some borrowers.
LightStream shines with its versatility and no-fee structure, offering competitive loan products for new purchases, lease buyouts, and refinancing. The availability of same-day funding and the absence of collateral requirements make it appealing for borrowers seeking convenience and flexibility. However, the lack of prequalification and supplementary protections like GAP insurance may deter borrowers who value these features. Additionally, LightStream is best suited for those with strong credit profiles, which could limit accessibility for borrowers with weaker credit.
Conclusion
Caribou and LightStream serve different purposes, with Caribou excelling in auto loan refinancing and LightStream standing out for its comprehensive loan options and fee-free structure. Borrowers focused on refinancing and additional vehicle-related protections may find Caribou to be the better fit. Meanwhile, those seeking new or used car loans, lease buyouts, or refinancing with no fees and fast funding are likely to prefer LightStream. Assessing your financial needs and loan goals will help determine which platform is the best choice for your situation.